2026-11-04 · 6 min read

FCAW and GMAW are both wire-fed processes and both are bought for the same reason: deposition rate. The difference is what is inside the wire. A solid wire is metal all the way through and relies entirely on the shielding gas. A flux-cored wire is a steel tube filled with flux, and that filling does part of the shielding gas’ job.

The structural difference

Solid wire (GMAW)Flux-cored wire (FCAW)
Cross-sectionSolid metal, copper-coatedSteel tube with a flux core
ShieldingExternal gas, alwaysExternal gas or none, depending on the grade
SlagNoneA slag layer that has to be removed between passes
Typical reachShop work, clean plate, good gas supplyField work, wind, thicker sections, higher deposition
Our gradesER70S-6E71T-1C (CO2 shielded), E71T-GS (self-shielded)

The middle two rows are the ones that decide most purchases. Solid wire has no slag, which means no cleaning between passes and no slag inclusions if the operator is careless. Flux-cored wire has slag, which costs cleaning time but pays it back in deposition and in tolerance of the plate.

The wind question

Gas shielding is a stream of gas blown at the puddle, and a breeze blows it away. This is why GMAW outdoors is a losing argument: the wire is fine, the process is fine, and the joint is porous because the shield never reached it. Self-shielded flux-cored wire exists for exactly this. E71T-GS carries its shielding inside the wire and needs no gas at all, so it works in wind, on site, and where hauling a cylinder is impractical.

Gas-shielded cored wire is a different animal

E71T-1C is flux-cored and gas-shielded, which sounds like the worst of both worlds until you look at what it is for. The C in the designation states CO2 as the shielding medium, and the rutile slag system gives a smooth bead in all positions with a deposition rate a solid wire of the same diameter does not reach. It is the shop-floor wire: good gas supply, good extraction, and a lot of metres to lay down.

Note the polarity difference, because it is the most common setting error between the two families. Self-shielded cored wires run on one polarity and gas-shielded cored wires on the other. Check the wire’s own datasheet rather than assuming, and check it again when you change from one grade to another on the same machine.

How to choose

  • Indoors, clean plate, thin to medium sections, appearance matters: solid wire with gas. ER70S-6.
  • Indoors, thicker sections, long runs, deposition rate is the cost driver: gas-shielded cored wire. E71T-1C.
  • Outdoors, wind, no gas supply, site work: self-shielded cored wire. E71T-GS.
  • Positional work at height with no gas: self-shielded cored wire, and accept a rougher bead.

Two warnings worth having in writing. First, self-shielded wire is not a substitute for gas-shielded wire on thickness — its deposition and its bead appearance are a compromise made for portability. Second, switching between the two families on one machine means changing polarity, drive rolls and often the liner. Plan for it rather than discovering it at the start of a shift.

What we supply

ER70S-6 to AWS A5.18 in 0.6 mm to 1.6 mm, copper-coated, DCEP. E71T-1C to AWS A5.20 in 0.8 mm to 1.6 mm for CO2. E71T-GS to AWS A5.20 in 0.9 mm to 1.6 mm, no gas. All three are in stock sizes and all three can be quoted together if you want to run the comparison on a real job rather than on a data sheet.